ianstone
06-08-2010, 01:00 PM
Brain scans being misused as lie detectors, experts say
By Caroline Parkinson
Health reporter, BBC News
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/999999.gif
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/47998000/jpg/_47998247_mri.jpg MRI scans are an established way of diagnosing brain conditions
Measures are needed to stop brain scans being misused by courts, insurers and employers, experts have warned. Some research suggests the technique can show whether a person is lying if certain areas of the brain "light-up".
At least one US company is offering scans to employers recruiting staff but American courts have already rejected attempts to use them in legal cases.
The University of Edinburgh's Burkhard Schafer said there were issues over privacy and reliability of technology.
The subject is being discussed by experts from around the world at a conference at the Institute of Advanced Studies in Glasgow.
'The next frontier'
Attempts have been made to use magnetic resonance imaging scans as lie detectors or to demonstrate mental health problems in more than 90 capital punishment cases in the US, as well as in other proceedings in Europe and Asia.
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gifhttp://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/start_quote_rb.gif As soon as public awareness increases there will be interest from everyone from daytime entertainment programmes to employers and the legal system http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/end_quote_rb.gif
Burkhard Schafer, University of Edinburgh
While they have been rejected in many cases, scan results have sometimes been accepted as evidence.
Mr Schafer, co-director of the SCRIPT Centre for Research in Intellectual Property and Technology at the University of Edinburgh's school of law, said the UK had to consider how to prevent MRI scans being misused - and how to protect people's privacy.
"After data mining and online profiling, brain imaging could well become the next frontier in the privacy wars.
"The promise to read a person's mind is beguiling, and some applications will be greatly beneficial.
"But a combination of exaggerated claims by commercial providers, inadequate legal regulation and the persuasive power of images bring very real dangers for us as citizens."
He added: "As soon as public awareness increases there will be interest from everyone from daytime entertainment programmes to employers and the legal system.
"It would be sensible to be prepared."
'Powerful and compelling'
Mr Schafer added there was also a chance employers could seek to use scans to test the honesty of an individual's CV - or by insurance companies.
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gifhttp://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/start_quote_rb.gif We do need to have an informed debate http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/end_quote_rb.gif
Professor Geraint Rees, UCL
"There should probably be a moratorium for insurance companies, as has happened over the use of genetic test information."
But he warned MRI scans should not be used in this way: "The science isn't there."
Joanna Wardlaw, professor of applied neuroimaging at the University of Edinburgh, said brain scans could show differences between groups who thought differently in a research setting.
But she added: "It's very, very difficult to apply the results of an individual's scan in situations such as where there is a threat of legal action.
"Images are powerful and compelling, and people are likely to accept them. But there needs to be much more understanding of what the limitations are."
Professor Geraint Rees, director of the University College London's Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, said: "I'm concerned about the potential use of scans that are starting to emerge now, but whether we need to go down the road of legal regulation, I'm not so sure about.
"But we do need to have an informed debate."
SEE ALSO
Brain scans 'may help spot liars' (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/8672400.stm)
10 May 10 | Health
Can brain scans detect criminals? (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4268260.stm)
21 Sep 05 | Health
Brain scan 'can read your mind' (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/6346069.stm)
09 Feb 07 | Health
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gif
RELATED INTERNET LINKS
University of Edinburgh (http://www.ed.ac.uk/home)
UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience (http://www.icn.ucl.ac.uk/)
By Caroline Parkinson
Health reporter, BBC News
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/999999.gif
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/47998000/jpg/_47998247_mri.jpg MRI scans are an established way of diagnosing brain conditions
Measures are needed to stop brain scans being misused by courts, insurers and employers, experts have warned. Some research suggests the technique can show whether a person is lying if certain areas of the brain "light-up".
At least one US company is offering scans to employers recruiting staff but American courts have already rejected attempts to use them in legal cases.
The University of Edinburgh's Burkhard Schafer said there were issues over privacy and reliability of technology.
The subject is being discussed by experts from around the world at a conference at the Institute of Advanced Studies in Glasgow.
'The next frontier'
Attempts have been made to use magnetic resonance imaging scans as lie detectors or to demonstrate mental health problems in more than 90 capital punishment cases in the US, as well as in other proceedings in Europe and Asia.
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gifhttp://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/start_quote_rb.gif As soon as public awareness increases there will be interest from everyone from daytime entertainment programmes to employers and the legal system http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/end_quote_rb.gif
Burkhard Schafer, University of Edinburgh
While they have been rejected in many cases, scan results have sometimes been accepted as evidence.
Mr Schafer, co-director of the SCRIPT Centre for Research in Intellectual Property and Technology at the University of Edinburgh's school of law, said the UK had to consider how to prevent MRI scans being misused - and how to protect people's privacy.
"After data mining and online profiling, brain imaging could well become the next frontier in the privacy wars.
"The promise to read a person's mind is beguiling, and some applications will be greatly beneficial.
"But a combination of exaggerated claims by commercial providers, inadequate legal regulation and the persuasive power of images bring very real dangers for us as citizens."
He added: "As soon as public awareness increases there will be interest from everyone from daytime entertainment programmes to employers and the legal system.
"It would be sensible to be prepared."
'Powerful and compelling'
Mr Schafer added there was also a chance employers could seek to use scans to test the honesty of an individual's CV - or by insurance companies.
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gifhttp://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/start_quote_rb.gif We do need to have an informed debate http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/v3/end_quote_rb.gif
Professor Geraint Rees, UCL
"There should probably be a moratorium for insurance companies, as has happened over the use of genetic test information."
But he warned MRI scans should not be used in this way: "The science isn't there."
Joanna Wardlaw, professor of applied neuroimaging at the University of Edinburgh, said brain scans could show differences between groups who thought differently in a research setting.
But she added: "It's very, very difficult to apply the results of an individual's scan in situations such as where there is a threat of legal action.
"Images are powerful and compelling, and people are likely to accept them. But there needs to be much more understanding of what the limitations are."
Professor Geraint Rees, director of the University College London's Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience, said: "I'm concerned about the potential use of scans that are starting to emerge now, but whether we need to go down the road of legal regulation, I'm not so sure about.
"But we do need to have an informed debate."
SEE ALSO
Brain scans 'may help spot liars' (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/8672400.stm)
10 May 10 | Health
Can brain scans detect criminals? (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4268260.stm)
21 Sep 05 | Health
Brain scan 'can read your mind' (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/6346069.stm)
09 Feb 07 | Health
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gif
RELATED INTERNET LINKS
University of Edinburgh (http://www.ed.ac.uk/home)
UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience (http://www.icn.ucl.ac.uk/)